This is a family favorite during the holidays as one of the dozens of variety of cookies that appear among the Christmas cookie platter. I prefer to make it at other times throughout the year, I find at Christmas there are just TOO MANY delicious cookies to choose from and in my opinion, to fully appreciate the yumminess of Buckeyes they should not compete with other baked goods.
When I make Buckeyes, I find myself extremely thankful for the electric stand mixer- I’d highly recommend using yours. Peanut butter is just such a thick, sticky product to work with. You’ll notice I also substituted some dairy free products for the traditional diary laden items. I find, no one misses the dairy!
Buckeyes
Ingredients
3 cups confectioners’ sugar
1 cup creamy peanut butter
4 tablespoons (1/2 stick) vegan butter substitute (room temperature)
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
3 cups semisweet chocolate chips (Your choice of dairy free)
- Prepare 2 baking sheets (that will fit in your freezer) by laying parchment paper on each sheet.
- Add the sugar, peanut butter, vegan butter substitute, and vanilla to the electric mixer bowl. Using the paddle attachment, beat the ingredients together. (A hand held mixer will also work in a pinch). Beat until the dough is crumbly. (See hint 1 below)
- Roll the doll into 1 inch balls, placing them on the parchment paper. Place the baking sheets in the freezer to chill for one hour.
- Using a double boiler (see hint 2 below), melt the chocolate chips in the by bringing the water to a boil. You will need to stir the chocolate frequently so it melts evenly. I DO NOT recommend using the microwave for this- it is too easy to ruin the temper of the chocolate.
- Once the chocolate has melted, use a toothpick to pierce the peanut butter ball, and carefully dip into the melted chocolate. Have a fork handy in case the tooth pick slips out. If the peanut butter balls keep slipping off of the toothpick you are probably dipping for too long- try to make it a quick process. Allow excess chocolate to drip off before returning to baking sheet. Repeat until you have dipped all the peanut butter balls.
- Allow the chocolate to harden, then carefully remove and place in a wax paper lined airtight container, refrigerate overnight before serving.
HINT 1: If the dough gets too hard to work with and is not sticking together, refrigerate it until chilled, this will make it easier to work with.
HINT 2: If you don’t have a double boiler (I do not), fret not. I use two pots that fit snugly together, allowing me to add water the larger one and fitting the smaller one inside of the larger one so it “floats” in a few inches of water.